[jacobsore]

No, why would you, this is an Applian forum, where you push Applian products. Understood. But now it's time for a lesson:

If you think all of TV, everywhere, is copyrighted, then yes, there is no reason to continue this discussion. For example, most of our TV in Europe is not copyrighted, since it comes from TV licensing fees (they tax how many TVs we have). There are channels and programs in the states that carry the same or similar quality as being supported by government taxes, although understandably less so than the rest of the world. For example, it is legal to record a high school football game, or even a program supported by the US government like an Army ad or all of Fox News (kidding).

I use an Applian product that is very clearly breaking several DRMs and laws, and I'm proud of it. But I just don't think you or Applian is in any position to question the legalities of anyone elses products. People should be fighting back to companies (mostly from the states) who are pushing DRM aggressively and preventing fair use.

As you said in your comparison, mReplay Live is in the same legal category as YouTube, as providers of online tools to allow, but who also discourage copyright infringement.