I tried both TR and
Replay Music (RM) 3, here's my thoughts
TR - powerful but complicated a bit. Didn't find where to adjust automated track splitting and tag setting for several files (i.e. when recording an album). Recording directly to MP3. Solid and reliable.
RM 3 - easy with one-touch setup. Smooth track spltting. Easy tag handling. But sometime mp3 conversion freezes on song identification. Recording in WAV and then converting it to MP3.
I had compared spectrums in WAV/PCM and 192 kbit MP3 via Adobe Audition. I think, RM3 produces slightly better, "meaty" WAV from stream than TR does, resulting in better MP3 encoding.
I'm on RM3, but will give TR extensive testing.