I've received a confirmation from a
Replay Music developer, that he had tested MusicBrainz. He claims that Gracenote DB is much better.
Bottom line:
- Use software supporting FreeDB or Musicbrainz for you CDs like Tag and Rename, MusicBrainz Tagger.
- Use Replay Music to record music from online radio stations or online music subscription services (automatical tagging of individual songs is supported)
- Use free Musicbrainz software to tag other individual songs. Although PicardTagger is CD oriented now, so I have no software suggestions so far.