Audio/video stream recording forums (http://stream-recorder.com/forum/index.php)

- Video stream recording (http://stream-recorder.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=4)

- -

Is it legal to record video streams? Can it be considered as a piracy?

(http://stream-recorder.com/forum/showthread.php?t=2036)

Re: Is it legal to record video streams? Can it be considered as a piracy?

It's doesn't matter legal or illegal to record video streaming. it will be illegal and counted as piracy if you will share your recorded video publicly. So if you recording it for just your entertainment purpose then it doesn't matter about legality or illegality.

Re: Is it legal to record video streams? Can it be considered as a piracy?

Hi,
Well it depends, if your are recording for personal use then it cant be considered illegal but in any other case .. It is completely illegal..

Re: Is it legal to record video streams? Can it be considered as a piracy?

Quote:

Originally Posted by miley tipton (Post 23088)

Hi,
Well it depends, if your are recording for personal use then it cant be considered illegal but in any other case .. It is completely illegal..

Right, if one uses anything not to get any profit and only for one's personal goals then it's absolutely legal.

Re: Is it legal to record video streams? Can it be considered as a piracy?

I think recording video is not illegal. But then what I think is illegal is the distribution of those recorded videos. If you keep it for personal use, I don't think it is going to be punishable.

Re: Is it legal to record video streams? Can it be considered as a piracy?

Quote:

§ 1008. Prohibition on certain infringement actions
No action may be brought under this title alleging infringement of copyright based on the manufacture, importation, or distribution of a digital audio recording device, a digital audio recording medium, an analog recording device, or an analog recording medium, or based on the noncommercial use by a consumer of such a device or medium for making digital musical recordings or analog musical recordings.

Quote:

Originally Posted by cliff@freeolamail.com (Post 22502)

Cliff's statement is an exaggeration, and IMHO is incorrect.

Section 1008 of the Act makes non-commercial use lawful, in the USA. In this context, 'commercial' carries its ordinary meaning, i.e. a payment. File sharing traditionally involves no payment, as the person sharing the file gives it away, i.e. for free. Hence it would appear to be noncommercial activity, which the Act permits.

Re: Is it legal to record video streams? Can it be considered as a piracy?

I don't give a damn whether it is legal or illegal to record video streams. It won't stop me to record it if I think it's worthy.

Re: Is it legal to record video streams? Can it be considered as a piracy?

Personally, I think it's wrong. Go and buy a magazine !

Re: Is it legal to record video streams? Can it be considered as a piracy?

It all depends what you're downloading, for instance, the BBC are public owned, we're forced by law to pay them a TV licence, so all BBC made stuff comes under fair use

What I mean is you can't own a TV or even just a computer without being forced to pay the BBC a licence every year, and it doesn't even matter if you never flick it on any of their channels

So all BBC financed stuff comes under fair use, hence why we don't see any copyright warnings when we upload BBC stuff to Youtube. I could even email them and tell them that I'm uploading their stuff and they wouldn't remove it

Re: Is it legal to record video streams? Can it be considered as a piracy?

If you never share to others it mean not piracy. But if you share in any means now it will become a piracy.

Re: Is it legal to record video streams? Can it be considered as a piracy?

Quote:

Originally Posted by jemelle

If you never share to others it mean not piracy

That makes about as much sense as

"Its not robbing a bank if you never share the money"