[cremefresh]

Hello,
I use rtmpdump.exe since over half a year for rtmpe streams, on my Windows XP system. I use ABP to find the rtmpe stream links and the command c:\rtmpdump.exe -r "rtmpe://link" -o example.flv

I have everything up-to-date *adobe, rtmpdump.exe* For rtmp streams I have streamtransport and replay media catcher.

But since two days rtmpdump.exe doesn`t work like before.

I wanted to download a video from Spike.com
c:\rtmpdump.exe -r "rtmpe://cp22372.edgefcs.net/ondemand/mtvnorigin/contentstore/media/2/9/0/5/7/2905762_700.flv" -o 1.flv

But the program opens and just closes fast just right the moment after, and there is this error message:
WARNING: HandShake: Type mismatch: client sent 6, server answered 9.
or
"no:// in url"

I re-checked some old videodownloads and now I cannot download the same videos which worked perfectly before, like from uma:mtv or vh-1, or msn. *never had problems before, everything worked perfect, also regular or being online meanwhile with a proxy*

I hope you can help me to find out what is wrong. :(

[hyc]

Type 9 RTMPE handshakes are not yet supported in rtmpdump (http://all-streaming-media.com/record-video-stream/rtmpdump-freeware-console-RTMP-downloading-application.htm).

[Monster]

Hi!

I'm just replying as there is no funktion to subscribe to this thread without replying I guess.

I have spent the hole day in order to get around this handshake error and finally endet up here.

As rtmpdump does not support type 9 handshakes, there will be no further searching - I will just have to wait for an update, right?

Greetings,

Mo

[Stream Recorder]

I'm just replying as there is no funktion to subscribe to this thread without replying I guess.
Click onto the following link to subscribe to this thread:
http://stream-recorder.com/forum/subscription.php?do=addsubscription&t=8603

Or just click onto "Thread Tools" above and select "Subscribe to this thread".

[nullacht]

But since two days rtmpdump.exe doesn`t work like before.

I wanted to download a video from Spike.com


RTMPDump v2.1d works flawlessly, while RTMPDump v2.3 fails...

http://www.spike.com/full-episodes/lehjxa/1000-ways-to-die-better-them-than-us-season-3-ep-320

rtmpdump -r "rtmpe://cp22372.edgefcs.net:1935/ondemand?ovpfv=2.1.4" -a "ondemand?ovpfv=2.1.4" -W "http://media.mtvnservices.com/player/prime/mediaplayerprime.1.6.0.swf" -y "mp4:mtvnorigin/gsp.spike-assets/spikecomstor/media/shows/1000wd/s04/e05/1000wd_s04e05_act1_1280x720_3500_h32.mp4" -o 1000wd_s04e05_act1_1280x720_3500_h32.flv

RTMPDump v2.1d:

RTMPDump v2.1d
(c) 2010 Andrej Stepanchuk, Howard Chu, The Flvstreamer Team; license: GPL
Connecting ...
Starting download at: 0.000 kB
Metadata:
duration 374.01
moovPosition 36.00
width 1280.00
height 720.00
videocodecid avc1
audiocodecid mp4a
avcprofile 100.00
avclevel 32.00
aacaot 2.00
videoframerate 29.97
audiosamplerate 22050.00
audiochannels 2.00
trackinfo:
length 1120500.00
timescale 2997.00
sampledescription:
sampletype avc1
length 8246873.00
timescale 22050.00
sampledescription:
sampletype mp4a
length 600.00
timescale 600.00
sampledescription:
length 600.00
timescale 600.00
sampledescription:
160054.690 kB / 374.01 sec (100.0%)
Download complete

RTMPDump v2.3:


RTMPDump v2.3
(c) 2010 Andrej Stepanchuk, Howard Chu, The Flvstreamer Team; license: GPL
Connecting ...
WARNING: HandShake: Type mismatch: client sent 6, server answered 9
WARNING: HandShake: Server not genuine Adobe!
ERROR: RTMP_Connect1, handshake failed.

[cybertot]

This didn't work for me on some of the other main sites

[SpaceMonkeyGuy]

I'm currently facing this problem as well, although I can't get round it by using XP/Vista as I'm in linux. Any suggestions? I tried using older 2.1d builds but then all I get are errors relating to NetConnection.Connect.Rejected> and [ AccessManager.Reject ] : Access denied!> :confused:

[nullacht]

Note: The issue was already fixed. Get the latest SVN version (r563).

svn://svn.mplayerhq.hu/rtmpdump/trunk

[MickJT]

Note: The issue was already fixed. Get the latest SVN version (r563).

svn://svn.mplayerhq.hu/rtmpdump/trunk

It still doesn't work on the YouTube RTMPE stream I've tried. I can PM you the link if you want it.

[hyc]

The patch in svn only allows rtmpdump (http://all-streaming-media.com/record-video-stream/rtmpdump-freeware-console-RTMP-downloading-application.htm) to continue to work with Flash servers that still support Flash 9.x clients. There are many servers out there now that require Flash 10.x clients and in that case, rtmpe type 9 is still needed.

[MickJT]

I hope support for it is being worked on.

[srpenn82]

Thanks for the instructions they worked - to a point at least.

I can get rtmpsrv to give me a command but when I try run it I get a failure due to a type 9 header.

Any ideas if there is a workaround?

to my knowledge there is no workaround at this time.

[nanobots]

Yep same problem, more and more sites must be updating because most of the content I try and record gives the type mismatch now.

Connecting ...
WARNING: HandShake: Type mismatch: client sent 6, server answered 9
WARNING: HandShake: Server not genuine Adobe!
ERROR: RTMP_Connect1, handshake failed.

[jake33]

I need this for YouTube downloads. Using rtmpsuck, I keep getting:

WARNING: HandShake: Type mismatch: client sent 6, server answered 9
WARNING: HandShake: Server not genuine Adobe!
ERROR: RTMP_Connect1, handshake failed.

This occurs on many YouTube videos that use RTMPE, such as:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=njuxnadQhC8
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Upixi7mM9hE
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8wxOVn99FTE
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E7JLSryoD8c
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2b8cTYrQ5-M


Does anyone have an idea when a fix will be available? (just so I know and can plan...)

[svnpenn]

"Does anyone have an idea when a fix will be available? (just so I know and can plan...)"

to my knowledge no one is even working on this

[sam4037]

why is noone working on this? can we have an update on the situation please? will rtmpdump (http://all-streaming-media.com/record-video-stream/rtmpdump-freeware-console-RTMP-downloading-application.htm) be useless in the future in that case?

[placebo]

gruessachsammo FREEWARE rtmpdump still works perfectly with most/many websites. otherwise the author hyc (http://stream-recorder.com/forum/member.php?u=21790) would have worked on it ;)

it doesnt harm to have several alternative tools (and 1 favourite tool) at hand, so if rtmpdump fails you would try the other tools (e.g. Jaksta). and as long as there exists 1 solution to a particular streaming downloading task, i am relaxed and dont wonder too much about the other not working tools. and when all tools fail, then i begin to complain about those tools for which i had paid $$$money. paying customers always have a right to "demand" support :D

You may want to contact hyc and ask him about the next major update of the FREE rtmpdump..

For freeloading whiners like you, I couldn't care less.
dito

[hyc]

why is noone working on this?

Because rtmpdump users are cheap b@stards and don't pay anything to support it.
can we have an update on the situation please?

Can I have a pony?

You sound like you think you're entitled to it. Wake up - you're not entitled to anything. You got this far on a *gift*. Be grateful.
will rtmpdump (http://all-streaming-media.com/record-video-stream/rtmpdump-freeware-console-RTMP-downloading-application.htm) be useless in the future in that case?

It works for me. For freeloading whiners like you, I couldn't care less.

[nanobots]

I don't think there is "currently" any tool that works on RTMPE steams with servers that require Flash 10.x clients and rtmpe type 9.

Its relatively new in widespread usage so just give it time, as others have pointed out rtmpdump is freely coded so there is no obligation for the author to provide instant results.

Be patient, as it becomes a more widespread problem it will get more attention and hopefully be addressed. =/

[chap]

hyc

If you do not have any trouble, please explain why rtmpsusk is not working (in fact it should be - it's a transparent proxy) on Flash 10.x clients. For example:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2b8cTYrQ5-M

2b8cTYrQ5-M

Thank you in advance.

P.S sorry for my english:(

[KSV]

Youtube uses rtmpe protocol for protected videos. Encryption/Decryption keys are necessary to decipher the data sent by server. rtmpsuck is not totally transparent. it needs to handshake with server on it's own to get the keys. something like:

http://i.imgur.com/j9g7W.png

Above information is based on my own understanding. it may be wrong though. also wait for howard's reply.

[hyc]

Youtube uses rtmpe protocol for protected videos. Encryption/Decryption keys are necessary to decipher the data sent by server. rtmpsuck is not totally transparent. it needs to handshake with server on it's own to get the keys. something like:

http://i.imgur.com/j9g7W.png

Above information is based on my own understanding. it may be wrong though. also wait for howard's reply.

Yes. Your diagram is correct for the released version of rtmpsuck.

This is not the only way that rtmpsuck has to work; it is possible to make it fully transparent on Linux/Unix. I have not released the code for this.

[chap]

I have not released the code for this.
This is possible in the future?

[sam4037]

as always hyc manages to impress everyone with his arrogance, well done..

did not know he considers rtmpdump users "cheap bastards.."

merley asking for an update on the situation or general question about the use of rtmpdump will only reap you insults from hyc..

you can be proud of your behavior hyc..

[chap]

as always hyc manages to impress everyone with his arrogance, well done..

did not know he considers rtmpdump users "cheap bastards.."

merley asking for an update on the situation or general question about the use of rtmpdump will only reap you insults from hyc..

you can be proud of your behavior hyc..

I think insults are inappropriate. After all, a person may have family, children. No time (desire) to solve this problem. It seems to me it is worth waiting (this is not a doomsday).
IMHO.

[placebo]

as always hyc manages to impress everyone with his arrogance, well done..

did not know he considers rtmpdump users "cheap bastards.."

merley asking for an update on the situation or general question about the use of rtmpdump will only reap you insults from hyc..

you can be proud of your behavior hyc..
while imho there's nothing bad about a person being arrogant (i am so often myself :D), actually calling someone that name is bad because it sounds like an insult from your part in turn. there's no need to get down on a personal level and no further offending will be tolerated; it's offtopic (http://stream-recorder.com/forum/other-discussions-f28.html) anyway and further such comments or posts will be moved or deleted, thanks.

hyc (http://highlandsun.com/hyc/abend.html), or Howard Chu (http://highlandsun.com/bandinfo/howard.html), is a senior with a highly busy professional career and social life and serious with what he embarks on. Let's be glad and thankful that once in a while he checks in at our place, the SRF community (http://stream-recorder.com/forum/), to see how happily we kiddos and college juniors deploy (exploit) his program and help each other with it. please sam, dont spoil hyc's mood. show respect and write in a friendly tone and everything will be fine.

btw, you could show off your goodwill by donating a leap sum here (http://stream-recorder.com/forum/donations-rtmpdump-solve-type-9-rtmpe-handshake-t8922.html) ;)

[sam4037]

actually calling someone that name is bad because it sounds like an insult from your part in turn.

I quoted him, let's not forget that, don't make it sound like I go round insulting people! I merely asked for an update on the situation.


there's no need to get down on a personal level and no further offending will be tolerated;

Again, I asked for an update on the situation and did not insult anyone here nor was I writing in an unfriendly tone, far from it. Getting down on a personal level is something completely different. I don't even know him. Let's say it again, I asked for an update on the situation. Hope this is clear now. What more can I say than that?


please sam, dont spoil hyc's mood. show respect and write in a friendly tone and everything will be fine.

Is exactly what I am doing, but being insulted and throwing the entire userbase of rtmpdump in there is not acceptable, at least not to me, if you are fine with that, that is cool, I am not and I have merely quoted him on his rude and arrogant behaviour. I am not disrespectful or rude. Again I was asking for an update on the situation, the reply I got was neither friendly nor respectful. How does it make you feel when you ask for information and all you get back is an insult?


btw, you could show off your goodwill by donating a leap sum here (http://stream-recorder.com/forum/donations-rtmpdump-solve-type-9-rtmpe-handshake-t8922.html) ;)
Yes sure I will naturally enjoy giving my money to him now. :D

It is fine, I won't bother quoting him anymore and will refrain from discussion with him in the future. I have voiced my concern not only about myself but about the other users in this forum. This is not the only occasion that this has happened and if the moderating team here is fine with that I am happy to abide. I just find it sad that the community is willing or forced to being exposed to insults from this developer. Voicing my opinion on this is only fair. I have never in the forum been rude nor insulted anyone, I actually don't see the point in doing so online.

So placebo thanks for your reply and you can be sure for me this matter is forgotten and shall not be raised again. Thanks!

[placebo]

So placebo thanks for your reply and you can be sure for me this matter is forgotten and shall not be raised again. Thanks!
Thanks also sam for your voicing and sharing your opinion on all that. No more hard feelings then. So let's go on with life and continue where we had left off.. Good luck everyone! :)

[JoeSakic]

Hi all,

I've tried to follow the instructions from people here (thanks for that).

The original video can be found here:

http://www.vh1.com/video/misc/661814/like-rock-roll-and-radio-vh1-storytellers.jhtml

Ran URL Snooper to get the host address: viacomvh1strmfs.fplive.net

Got rtmpsrv running, and got the following command line from it:

rtmpdump -r "rtmpe://viacomvh1strmfs.fplive.net:1935/viacomvh1strm" -a "viacomvh1strm" -f "WIN 10,3,181,34" -W "http://media.mtvnservices.com/player/prime/mediaplayerprime.1.9.0.swf?uri=mgid:uma:video:vh1. com:661814&type=network&ref=www.vh1.com&geo=US&group=music&&CONFIG_URL=http%3a%2f%2fwww.vh1.com%2fplayer%2femb ed%2fAS3%2fconfiguration.jhtml%3furi%3dmgid%3auma% 3avideo%3avh1.com%3a661814%26type%3dnetwork%26ref% 3dwww.vh1.com%26geo%3dUS%26group%3dmusic%26ver%3dp rime%26instance%3dvh1%26id%3d1665385%26vid%3d66181 4" -p "http://www.vh1.com/video/misc/661814/like-rock-roll-and-radio-vh1-storytellers.jhtml" -C O:1 -C NB:0:0 -C NS:1:mp4:gsp.vhonecomstor/vh1.com/shows/storytellers/ray_lamontagne/vh_storytellers_ray_lamontagne_rt241429_act1_640x3 60_1200_m30.mp4 -C O:0 -y "mp4:gsp.vhonecomstor/vh1.com/shows/storytellers/ray_lamontagne/vh_storytellers_ray_lamontagne_rt241429_act1_640x3 60_1200_m30.mp4" -o vh_storytellers_ray_lamontagne_rt241429_act1_640x3 60_1200_m30.mp4

I then tried to run it this rtmpdump command line and got the following error:

RTMPDump v2.3
(c) 2010 Andrej Stepanchuk, Howard Chu, The Flvstreamer Team; license: GPL
Connecting ...
WARNING: HandShake: Type mismatch: client sent 6, server answered 9
WARNING: HandShake: Server not genuine Adobe!
ERROR: RTMP_Connect1, handshake failed.

Any help would be greatly appreciated. BTW, running Windows XP

Thanks.

[chap]

http://stream-recorder.com/forum/showpost.php?p=30507&postcount=2

[JoeSakic]

Thanks for that. I don't know if you are on the development team or know any one on the development team, but any idea when rtmpdump (http://all-streaming-media.com/record-video-stream/rtmpdump-freeware-console-RTMP-downloading-application.htm) will support type 9 handshake?

Thanks.

[svnpenn]

No one is even working on the RTMPE type 9 handshake. So rtmpdump (http://all-streaming-media.com/record-video-stream/rtmpdump-freeware-console-RTMP-downloading-application.htm) will support after someone starts working on it

[Stream Recorder]

The type 9 handshake has been deciphered. Download rtmpdump (http://all-streaming-media.com/record-video-stream/rtmpdump-freeware-console-RTMP-downloading-application.htm) 2.4 and test it:
http://stream-recorder.com/forum/showpost.php?p=30836&postcount=17

Here is how to donate to the developers:
Donations for rtmpdump to solve the type 9 rtmpe handshake problem

[chap]

Finally support for RTMPE type 9 has been added.
Who did it is the best guy! :cool:
Thanks.

[JoeSakic]

To the RTMPE team,

Thanks so much for adding RTMPE type 9.

I really appreciate the effort to do this.

Thanks again :)

[sam4037]

Just read that type 9 is now supported and wanted to wholeheartedly thank Howard or whoever else did update the code. Thanks for that. I know you can't buy yourself anything from it but rest assured if we ever meet in person I will surly buy you a beer or a coffee. No really, thanks, this is MUCH appreciated! :D

[workoutbgc]

Hi im new to this forum and I started using rtmpdump with rtmpexplorer and I keep getting a handshake error with a video im trying to get from amazon. Ive been able to get other episodes from there just not this one.I attached the log

[svnpenn]

Hi im new to this forum and I started using rtmpdump with rtmpexplorer and I keep getting a handshake error with a video im trying to get from amazon

Requires login; post or send login info.

[chap]

Hi im new to this forum and I started using rtmpdump with rtmpexplorer and I keep getting a handshake error with a video im trying to get from amazon.

INFO: Metadata:
INFO: duration 2617.09
INFO: moovPosition 28.00
INFO: width 640.00
INFO: height 480.00
INFO: videocodecid encv
INFO: audiocodecid enca
you can not look:(